Lépjen offline állapotba az Player FM alkalmazással!
Exploring Human History: Insights from 'Sapiens' by Yuval Noah Harari
Manage episode 438044701 series 2812281
Chapter 1:Summary of Sapiens
"Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind" by Yuval Noah Harari is a wide-ranging narrative that spans the history of the human species from the emergence of the first homo species to the present day. The book discusses how Homo sapiens came to dominate the world, identifying key revolutionary periods that have shaped human society.
The book is generally divided into four major parts, based on what Harari identifies as major revolutions in human history: the Cognitive Revolution, the Agricultural Revolution, the Unification of Humankind, and the Scientific Revolution.
1. Cognitive Revolution (c. 70,000 years ago): Harari suggests that about 70,000 years ago, Homo sapiens began to develop unique ways of thinking and communicating, such as the ability to believe in abstract concepts (like gods, nations, and human rights), the power of storytelling, and more complex societal structures. This set sapiens apart from other human species.
2. Agricultural Revolution (c. 12,000 years ago): It marks the transition from foraging and hunting to agriculture which led to the formation of permanent settlements and a significant increase in population. Harari argues this shift allowed for the accumulation of goods and an increase in social hierarchies but also led to harsher living conditions for most people.
3. Unification of Humankind: This refers to the gradual consolidation of human cultures into broader groups and eventually global unities. This involved the spread and clash of major empires, religions, and ideologies, which often led to the assimilation or wiping out of smaller cultures.
4. Scientific Revolution (c. 500 years ago): Beginning with the Age of Exploration and Technological advances, this period brought new understandings of the world. This revolution increased human power dramatically, particularly through developments in science and industry, shaping the modern world.
Harari discusses not only the past but also speculates on the future of humanity, touching on topics such as genetic engineering and artificial intelligence. Throughout "Sapiens", Harari maintains a critical tone, questioning whether developments like agriculture and industry have really improved our happiness and challenging the reader to think about what the future holds for a species that continues to break boundaries.
The narrative is supported by insights from anthropology, psychology, history, and economics, weaving a complex but engaging account of how we got to where we are and where we might be heading. Harari's book has been praised for its accessible prose and broad, interdisciplinary approach, though it has also faced criticism for oversimplifications and factual inaccuracies. Nonetheless, "Sapiens" has made significant contributions to public discussions about the understanding of human history and the future of humanity.
Chapter 2:The Theme of Sapiens
"Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind" by Yuval Noah Harari is a non-fiction work that explores the history of humanity from the emergence of Homo sapiens in the Stone Age up to the twenty-first century. The book is divided into four main parts, each exploring different pivotal stages in the journey of humankind. It does not have a narrative plot or character development in the traditional sense, as it is not a novel but rather an exploration of themes and concepts related to human history.
Key Plot Points
Though "Sapiens" does not have a "plot" in the conventional narrative sense, it can be broken down into several key points according to its divisions, which focus on major turning points in human history:
1. The Cognitive Revolution
- Harari discusses how about 70,000 years ago, Homo sapiens began to demonstrate unique ways of thinking and communicating, enabling them to out-compete other species and inhabit various environments. This revolution was characterized by the development of language, which allowed for more complex societies.
2. The Agricultural Revolution
- Around 10,000 years ago, humans began to domesticate plants and animals, which led to the establishment of permanent settlements and a shift from foraging to farming. This revolution drastically changed the structure of human societies and the environment, increasing food production but also leading to new forms of hierarchy and inequality.
3. The Unification of Humankind
- As human societies grew, they began to form larger social structures and universal norms, facilitated by empires, religions, and economic systems that began to connect disparate groups across the globe.
4. The Scientific Revolution
- Beginning around 500 years ago, this revolution sparked an unprecedented questioning of traditional knowledge and authority, leading to technological advancements and reshaping societies through industrialization and the modern capitalist economy.
Character Development
In "Sapiens," the "characters" are not individuals but rather entire human societies and the collective mindsets and behaviors of Homo sapiens. These character developments occur in terms of how societies evolve, adapt, and interact.
Thematic Ideas
"Sapiens" introduces several recurring themes throughout the progression of human history:
1. Cognitive Freedom and Social Constructs
- Harari emphasizes the idea that much of the historical and societal changes were based on shared beliefs and constructs that only exist in the collective human imagination, such as money, gods, nations, and human rights.
2. Imperialism and Cultural Homogenization
- The spread of empires and the rise of dominant cultures have led to both the enrichment of cultural exchanges and the destruction or diminishment of less dominant cultures.
3. Scientific Progress and Ethical Questions
- The technological advancements and their impacts on society raise questions about ethics and the future direction of human evolution, particularly concerns about biotechnology and artificial intelligence.
4. Environmental Impact
- Human activities, especially post-Agricultural Revolution, have led to significant environmental changes and extinctions, posing critical questions about sustainability and the ecological footprint of humankind.
5. Happiness and Suffering
- Despite technological and material advancements, Harari questions whether human beings have become happier through history, challenging the notion that progress always correlates with increased well-being.
Overall, "Sapiens" provides a broad and thought-provoking overview of human history, encouraging readers to reflect on where humankind has come from and where it is potentially headed.
Chapter 3:Meet the Writer of Sapiens
Yuval Noah Harari, through his book "Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind," demonstrates a distinct capacity for intertwining expansive historical analysis with engaging narrative elements, which makes complex ideas accessible and stimulating to a broad audience. His writing style and utilization of various literary techniques are essential to how he conveys the deeper emotions and meanings throughout the book. Below, we discuss a few key aspects of his writing skills and language style:
1. Narrative Structure: Harari employs a clear, structured narrative that flows from the cognitive revolution, through the agricultural revolution, and into the scientific revolution, among others. This chronological approach helps readers understand the progression of human societies and how each phase contributes to the emotional and intellectual evolution of humankind.
2. Interdisciplinary Approach: Harari integrates insights from genetics, anthropology, history, and economics, which enriches his narrative. This synthesis not only adds depth but also highlights the complexity and interconnectedness of human history, engaging readers emotionally by showing them the broad impact of historical shifts on human lives.
3. Analytical and Reflective Tone: Harari frequently steps back from the narrative to pose provocative questions or offer thoughtful reflections. This technique encourages readers to think critically about the material, engaging their intellectual and emotional faculties to ponder humanity's past decisions and future possibilities.
4. Use of Analogies and Metaphors: Harari effectively uses analogies and metaphors to simplify and clarify complex processes and ideas. For example, he compares the Code of Hammurabi to a modern legal system to illustrate the evolution of social norms and regulations. These comparisons not only make the information more relatable but also evoke the emotional context of these developments.
5. Inclusive Language: Harari often uses inclusive terms such as "we" and "us" when discussing the human species. This linguistic choice fosters a connection between the reader and the narrative, making the historical discourse more immersive and personally relevant.
6. Language Simplicity and Clarity: Despite the complexity of the topics, Harari's language remains clear and accessible, which is crucial for communicating effectively with a wide audience. This simplicity ensures that readers are not alienated by technical jargon, but rather, are drawn into the analysis through comprehensible and relatable terms.
7. Evocative Descriptions: Harari does not shy away from depicting the stark realities of human history, including the brutality and suffering that have often accompanied human progress. His vivid descriptions of historical events not only provide a clear picture but also aim to resonate emotionally with the reader, prompting a deeper contemplation of the ethical dimensions of our history.
8. Thematic Exploration: Themes such as power, happiness, and freedom are explored in depth. Harari challenges common assumptions and beliefs, pushing readers to explore emotional responses to these themes and their implications for human life.
By marrying accessible language with profound thematic inquiry, Harari not only educates his readers but also engages them emotionally, encouraging them to reflect on their own place within the broad tapestry of human history. It's this combination of intellectual stimulation and emotional engagement that has contributed significantly to the success of "Sapiens" and its impact on readers worldwide.
Chapter 4:Deeper Understanding of Sapiens
Yuval Noah Harari's book "Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind," first published in Hebrew in 2011 and later translated into English in 2014, has left an indelible mark on various facets of culture and society around the world. Its compelling narrative offers a broad exploration of the history of the human species from the emergence of Homo sapiens in the Stone Age up through the twenty-first century. Here’s a summary of its influence and significance:
1. Literature and Intellectual Discourse:
- Shift in Historical Narratives: "Sapiens" has influenced literature and intellectual discourse by offering a synthesis of history, biology, anthropology, and economics, which has encouraged other writers and academics to explore similar multidisciplinary approaches to complex topics.
- Popular Science and Non-Fiction: The book has been a commercial success, signaling an appetite among general readers for accessible yet intellectually engaging narratives. It has contributed to a trend in non-fiction where combining scientific insights with historical analysis is highly appealing to a broad audience.
2. Cultural Impact:
- Public Discourse and Media: Harari’s viewpoints and the concepts explored in "Sapiens" have been widely discussed in media outlets, literary festivals, and public debates, influencing how people understand human history and contemporary societal challenges.
- Documentaries and Talks: Harari's ideas have transcended the pages of his book to feature in various documentaries, public talks, and interviews accessible through platforms like TED, YouTube, and podcasts, reaching an even wider audience.
3. Social and Philosophical Influence:
- Ethical Reflections: The book prompts readers to reflect on ethical questions about capitalism, racism, colonialism, and the environmental impacts of human development. This has driven dialogue in academic and social contexts about the moral implications of history and human development.
- Debates on Human Future: By tracing past developments, "Sapiens" has stimulated discussions on the future trajectory of humans, particularly concerning genetic engineering, artificial intelligence, and potential societal restructuring.
4. Educational Impact:
- Academic Curricula: "Sapiens" has been incorporated into various educational curricula and reading lists across high schools and universities, encouraging students to engage critically with human history and its multifaceted impacts.
- Interdisciplinary Studies: It promotes an interdisciplinary approach that is increasingly valued in educational systems that strive to provide holistic understandings of complex global issues.
5. Influence in Modern Thought and Business:
- Corporate and Political Leaders: Influential figures in technology and business, such as Mark Zuckerberg and Bill Gates, have recommended the book, which suggests that its insights are being considered in the tech industry and other fields. Leaders in these spaces often seek to understand long-term human patterns and behaviors as a guide for future developments and strategy planning.
- Think Tanks and Strategic Planning: Concepts from "Sapiens" are utilized by think tanks and in strategic planning contexts, where understanding historical human behaviors can guide future policy and innovation.
In sum, "Sapiens" has not only altered the landscape of popular science writing but also holds a significant place in contemporary cultural and intellectual debates. Its broad, interdisciplinary approach invites readers and thinkers from various backgrounds to reassess fundamental questions about societal organization, ethical responsibilities, and the path forward for humanity.
Chapter 5:Quotes From Sapiens
"Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind" by Yuval Noah Harari is a popular book that explores the history of the human species, from the emergence of archaic human species to the present. Here are ten quotes from the book that encapsulate some of its key ideas:
1. "Biology enables, Culture forbids."
2. "History is something that very few people have been doing while everyone else was ploughing fields and carrying water buckets."
3. "Humans think in stories rather than in facts, numbers, or equations, and the simpler the story, the better."
4. "Money is the most universal and most efficient system of mutual trust ever devised."
5. "There is no justice in history. When we reap the fruits of history, we seldom remember the invisible people crying for justice that was not done."
6. "The most common reaction of the human mind to achievement is not satisfaction, but craving for more."
7. "You could never convince a monkey to give you a banana by promising him limitless bananas after death in monkey heaven."
8. "Happiness does not really depend on objective conditions of either wealth, health or even community. Rather, it depends on the correlation between objective conditions and subjective expectations."
9. "We study history not to know the future but to widen our horizons, to understand that our present situation is neither natural nor inevitable, and that we consequently have many more possibilities before us than we imagine."
10. "For thousands of years, philosophers, thinkers, and prophets have riddled history with inconsistencies, perplexities, and outrages. Yet, for some mysterious reason, life goes on."
These quotes offer a glimpse into Harari's expansive narrative on human history, exploring themes from economics, biology, and philosophy to politics and religion. Each quote reflects his overarching argument about the complexities of human culture and society.
Book https://www.bookey.app/book/sapiens
Author https://www.bookey.app/quote-author/yuval-noah-harari
Quotes https://www.bookey.app/quote-book/sapiens
YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DbRdZTP5xXU
1002 epizódok
Manage episode 438044701 series 2812281
Chapter 1:Summary of Sapiens
"Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind" by Yuval Noah Harari is a wide-ranging narrative that spans the history of the human species from the emergence of the first homo species to the present day. The book discusses how Homo sapiens came to dominate the world, identifying key revolutionary periods that have shaped human society.
The book is generally divided into four major parts, based on what Harari identifies as major revolutions in human history: the Cognitive Revolution, the Agricultural Revolution, the Unification of Humankind, and the Scientific Revolution.
1. Cognitive Revolution (c. 70,000 years ago): Harari suggests that about 70,000 years ago, Homo sapiens began to develop unique ways of thinking and communicating, such as the ability to believe in abstract concepts (like gods, nations, and human rights), the power of storytelling, and more complex societal structures. This set sapiens apart from other human species.
2. Agricultural Revolution (c. 12,000 years ago): It marks the transition from foraging and hunting to agriculture which led to the formation of permanent settlements and a significant increase in population. Harari argues this shift allowed for the accumulation of goods and an increase in social hierarchies but also led to harsher living conditions for most people.
3. Unification of Humankind: This refers to the gradual consolidation of human cultures into broader groups and eventually global unities. This involved the spread and clash of major empires, religions, and ideologies, which often led to the assimilation or wiping out of smaller cultures.
4. Scientific Revolution (c. 500 years ago): Beginning with the Age of Exploration and Technological advances, this period brought new understandings of the world. This revolution increased human power dramatically, particularly through developments in science and industry, shaping the modern world.
Harari discusses not only the past but also speculates on the future of humanity, touching on topics such as genetic engineering and artificial intelligence. Throughout "Sapiens", Harari maintains a critical tone, questioning whether developments like agriculture and industry have really improved our happiness and challenging the reader to think about what the future holds for a species that continues to break boundaries.
The narrative is supported by insights from anthropology, psychology, history, and economics, weaving a complex but engaging account of how we got to where we are and where we might be heading. Harari's book has been praised for its accessible prose and broad, interdisciplinary approach, though it has also faced criticism for oversimplifications and factual inaccuracies. Nonetheless, "Sapiens" has made significant contributions to public discussions about the understanding of human history and the future of humanity.
Chapter 2:The Theme of Sapiens
"Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind" by Yuval Noah Harari is a non-fiction work that explores the history of humanity from the emergence of Homo sapiens in the Stone Age up to the twenty-first century. The book is divided into four main parts, each exploring different pivotal stages in the journey of humankind. It does not have a narrative plot or character development in the traditional sense, as it is not a novel but rather an exploration of themes and concepts related to human history.
Key Plot Points
Though "Sapiens" does not have a "plot" in the conventional narrative sense, it can be broken down into several key points according to its divisions, which focus on major turning points in human history:
1. The Cognitive Revolution
- Harari discusses how about 70,000 years ago, Homo sapiens began to demonstrate unique ways of thinking and communicating, enabling them to out-compete other species and inhabit various environments. This revolution was characterized by the development of language, which allowed for more complex societies.
2. The Agricultural Revolution
- Around 10,000 years ago, humans began to domesticate plants and animals, which led to the establishment of permanent settlements and a shift from foraging to farming. This revolution drastically changed the structure of human societies and the environment, increasing food production but also leading to new forms of hierarchy and inequality.
3. The Unification of Humankind
- As human societies grew, they began to form larger social structures and universal norms, facilitated by empires, religions, and economic systems that began to connect disparate groups across the globe.
4. The Scientific Revolution
- Beginning around 500 years ago, this revolution sparked an unprecedented questioning of traditional knowledge and authority, leading to technological advancements and reshaping societies through industrialization and the modern capitalist economy.
Character Development
In "Sapiens," the "characters" are not individuals but rather entire human societies and the collective mindsets and behaviors of Homo sapiens. These character developments occur in terms of how societies evolve, adapt, and interact.
Thematic Ideas
"Sapiens" introduces several recurring themes throughout the progression of human history:
1. Cognitive Freedom and Social Constructs
- Harari emphasizes the idea that much of the historical and societal changes were based on shared beliefs and constructs that only exist in the collective human imagination, such as money, gods, nations, and human rights.
2. Imperialism and Cultural Homogenization
- The spread of empires and the rise of dominant cultures have led to both the enrichment of cultural exchanges and the destruction or diminishment of less dominant cultures.
3. Scientific Progress and Ethical Questions
- The technological advancements and their impacts on society raise questions about ethics and the future direction of human evolution, particularly concerns about biotechnology and artificial intelligence.
4. Environmental Impact
- Human activities, especially post-Agricultural Revolution, have led to significant environmental changes and extinctions, posing critical questions about sustainability and the ecological footprint of humankind.
5. Happiness and Suffering
- Despite technological and material advancements, Harari questions whether human beings have become happier through history, challenging the notion that progress always correlates with increased well-being.
Overall, "Sapiens" provides a broad and thought-provoking overview of human history, encouraging readers to reflect on where humankind has come from and where it is potentially headed.
Chapter 3:Meet the Writer of Sapiens
Yuval Noah Harari, through his book "Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind," demonstrates a distinct capacity for intertwining expansive historical analysis with engaging narrative elements, which makes complex ideas accessible and stimulating to a broad audience. His writing style and utilization of various literary techniques are essential to how he conveys the deeper emotions and meanings throughout the book. Below, we discuss a few key aspects of his writing skills and language style:
1. Narrative Structure: Harari employs a clear, structured narrative that flows from the cognitive revolution, through the agricultural revolution, and into the scientific revolution, among others. This chronological approach helps readers understand the progression of human societies and how each phase contributes to the emotional and intellectual evolution of humankind.
2. Interdisciplinary Approach: Harari integrates insights from genetics, anthropology, history, and economics, which enriches his narrative. This synthesis not only adds depth but also highlights the complexity and interconnectedness of human history, engaging readers emotionally by showing them the broad impact of historical shifts on human lives.
3. Analytical and Reflective Tone: Harari frequently steps back from the narrative to pose provocative questions or offer thoughtful reflections. This technique encourages readers to think critically about the material, engaging their intellectual and emotional faculties to ponder humanity's past decisions and future possibilities.
4. Use of Analogies and Metaphors: Harari effectively uses analogies and metaphors to simplify and clarify complex processes and ideas. For example, he compares the Code of Hammurabi to a modern legal system to illustrate the evolution of social norms and regulations. These comparisons not only make the information more relatable but also evoke the emotional context of these developments.
5. Inclusive Language: Harari often uses inclusive terms such as "we" and "us" when discussing the human species. This linguistic choice fosters a connection between the reader and the narrative, making the historical discourse more immersive and personally relevant.
6. Language Simplicity and Clarity: Despite the complexity of the topics, Harari's language remains clear and accessible, which is crucial for communicating effectively with a wide audience. This simplicity ensures that readers are not alienated by technical jargon, but rather, are drawn into the analysis through comprehensible and relatable terms.
7. Evocative Descriptions: Harari does not shy away from depicting the stark realities of human history, including the brutality and suffering that have often accompanied human progress. His vivid descriptions of historical events not only provide a clear picture but also aim to resonate emotionally with the reader, prompting a deeper contemplation of the ethical dimensions of our history.
8. Thematic Exploration: Themes such as power, happiness, and freedom are explored in depth. Harari challenges common assumptions and beliefs, pushing readers to explore emotional responses to these themes and their implications for human life.
By marrying accessible language with profound thematic inquiry, Harari not only educates his readers but also engages them emotionally, encouraging them to reflect on their own place within the broad tapestry of human history. It's this combination of intellectual stimulation and emotional engagement that has contributed significantly to the success of "Sapiens" and its impact on readers worldwide.
Chapter 4:Deeper Understanding of Sapiens
Yuval Noah Harari's book "Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind," first published in Hebrew in 2011 and later translated into English in 2014, has left an indelible mark on various facets of culture and society around the world. Its compelling narrative offers a broad exploration of the history of the human species from the emergence of Homo sapiens in the Stone Age up through the twenty-first century. Here’s a summary of its influence and significance:
1. Literature and Intellectual Discourse:
- Shift in Historical Narratives: "Sapiens" has influenced literature and intellectual discourse by offering a synthesis of history, biology, anthropology, and economics, which has encouraged other writers and academics to explore similar multidisciplinary approaches to complex topics.
- Popular Science and Non-Fiction: The book has been a commercial success, signaling an appetite among general readers for accessible yet intellectually engaging narratives. It has contributed to a trend in non-fiction where combining scientific insights with historical analysis is highly appealing to a broad audience.
2. Cultural Impact:
- Public Discourse and Media: Harari’s viewpoints and the concepts explored in "Sapiens" have been widely discussed in media outlets, literary festivals, and public debates, influencing how people understand human history and contemporary societal challenges.
- Documentaries and Talks: Harari's ideas have transcended the pages of his book to feature in various documentaries, public talks, and interviews accessible through platforms like TED, YouTube, and podcasts, reaching an even wider audience.
3. Social and Philosophical Influence:
- Ethical Reflections: The book prompts readers to reflect on ethical questions about capitalism, racism, colonialism, and the environmental impacts of human development. This has driven dialogue in academic and social contexts about the moral implications of history and human development.
- Debates on Human Future: By tracing past developments, "Sapiens" has stimulated discussions on the future trajectory of humans, particularly concerning genetic engineering, artificial intelligence, and potential societal restructuring.
4. Educational Impact:
- Academic Curricula: "Sapiens" has been incorporated into various educational curricula and reading lists across high schools and universities, encouraging students to engage critically with human history and its multifaceted impacts.
- Interdisciplinary Studies: It promotes an interdisciplinary approach that is increasingly valued in educational systems that strive to provide holistic understandings of complex global issues.
5. Influence in Modern Thought and Business:
- Corporate and Political Leaders: Influential figures in technology and business, such as Mark Zuckerberg and Bill Gates, have recommended the book, which suggests that its insights are being considered in the tech industry and other fields. Leaders in these spaces often seek to understand long-term human patterns and behaviors as a guide for future developments and strategy planning.
- Think Tanks and Strategic Planning: Concepts from "Sapiens" are utilized by think tanks and in strategic planning contexts, where understanding historical human behaviors can guide future policy and innovation.
In sum, "Sapiens" has not only altered the landscape of popular science writing but also holds a significant place in contemporary cultural and intellectual debates. Its broad, interdisciplinary approach invites readers and thinkers from various backgrounds to reassess fundamental questions about societal organization, ethical responsibilities, and the path forward for humanity.
Chapter 5:Quotes From Sapiens
"Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind" by Yuval Noah Harari is a popular book that explores the history of the human species, from the emergence of archaic human species to the present. Here are ten quotes from the book that encapsulate some of its key ideas:
1. "Biology enables, Culture forbids."
2. "History is something that very few people have been doing while everyone else was ploughing fields and carrying water buckets."
3. "Humans think in stories rather than in facts, numbers, or equations, and the simpler the story, the better."
4. "Money is the most universal and most efficient system of mutual trust ever devised."
5. "There is no justice in history. When we reap the fruits of history, we seldom remember the invisible people crying for justice that was not done."
6. "The most common reaction of the human mind to achievement is not satisfaction, but craving for more."
7. "You could never convince a monkey to give you a banana by promising him limitless bananas after death in monkey heaven."
8. "Happiness does not really depend on objective conditions of either wealth, health or even community. Rather, it depends on the correlation between objective conditions and subjective expectations."
9. "We study history not to know the future but to widen our horizons, to understand that our present situation is neither natural nor inevitable, and that we consequently have many more possibilities before us than we imagine."
10. "For thousands of years, philosophers, thinkers, and prophets have riddled history with inconsistencies, perplexities, and outrages. Yet, for some mysterious reason, life goes on."
These quotes offer a glimpse into Harari's expansive narrative on human history, exploring themes from economics, biology, and philosophy to politics and religion. Each quote reflects his overarching argument about the complexities of human culture and society.
Book https://www.bookey.app/book/sapiens
Author https://www.bookey.app/quote-author/yuval-noah-harari
Quotes https://www.bookey.app/quote-book/sapiens
YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DbRdZTP5xXU
1002 epizódok
Minden epizód
×Üdvözlünk a Player FM-nél!
A Player FM lejátszó az internetet böngészi a kiváló minőségű podcastok után, hogy ön élvezhesse azokat. Ez a legjobb podcast-alkalmazás, Androidon, iPhone-on és a weben is működik. Jelentkezzen be az feliratkozások szinkronizálásához az eszközök között.