Episode #45: Nash & special guest Phil cover the unbelievable story of that time some people in America lost their ever-loving minds & had themselves a vampire-related meltdown. (New England Vampire Panic, American Vampire Panic) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @…

Episode #44: Join Nash & Tiff as they continue to talk about some bizarre catastrophes that devastated homes & lives - disasters that were far from natural (the Centralia Pennsylvania fires) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hea…

Episode #43: Join Nash & Tiff as they talk about some bizarre catastrophes that devastated homes & lives - disasters that were far from natural. (Boston's Great Molasses Flood) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your persona…

Episode #42: Nash & Tiff collected some bonus content for their faithful listeners - outtakes, sidebars, and stuff that wouldn't fit in the regular episodes. There's also rants, complaints, and general wittiness. (PS: If you're new, start somewhere else, because none of this will make any sense *wink*) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog …

Mini-Episode #14 - Tiff tells Nash a true story about a time meat fell from the sky. No, really. (Hosts' Choice: the Kentucky meat shower) . Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or hometown stories, as well as suggestions for topics they'd like to hear us discuss, and sometimes things we w…

Episode #41: Nash & Tiff once asked you to join them as they talked about what could be hiding in the snow. Now they ask you to come along as they revisit one of those stories, because as you'll see, they just can't let it go. That was a bad joke. But seriously, did the movie "Frozen" really solve the Dyatlov Pass Mystery? Let's find out. (Dyatlov …

Episode #40: Nash & Tiff are celebrating the second anniversary of You Totally Made That Up with a special “best of” episode full of their favorite moments from the past year! . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal…

Episode #39: Come along as Nash & Tiff examine two medical marvels - one has a stomach seemingly made of steel & the other has a brain that doesn't give up. (Tarrare, Phineas Gage) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your per…

Mini-Episode #13 - Nash surprises Tiff with a story related to the Zodiac Killer that involves bunnies, an ice cream freezer, a motorcycle, urinal faux pas, and getting a guy fired. (Hosts' Choice: "The Zodiac Killer" movie) . Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or hometown stories, as we…

Episode #38: It's a surprise episode for the Ho-Ho-Ho-holiday, in which Nash & Tiff talk about times when Christmas was *actually* cancelled. There's also fancy nuts. And those pesky wassables. And soooo many tables. (Christmas is cancelled, Christmas carols, Puritans and Christmas, Christmas traditions, Victorian Christmas, Teddy Roosevelt, Christ…

Episode #37: Nash & Tiff continue their discussion of famous "cursed" houses & the people whose lives were impacted by them - plus some bonus true crime content! (the Amityville Horror, DeFeo family murders) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |…

Episode #36: This time, Nash & Tiff talk about famous "cursed" houses & the people whose lives were impacted by them. (the Winchester Mystery House, Sarah Winchester) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal & local …

Episode #35: This Thanksgiving, join Nash & Tiff as they discuss some American folktales that actually have some truths behind them. (Johnny Appleseed, Davy Crockett) | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal & local cr…

Episode #34: You knew it was coming - here's part 2 of the Halloween episode, where Nash & Tiff continue their discussion of two of the world's most famous monsters... and their creators... and bad accents, somehow. (Bram Stoker, Dracula, Vlad the Impaler) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @Y…

Episode #33: To celebrate Halloween, Nash & Tiff discuss two of the world's most famous monsters... and their creators. (Mary Shelley, Frankenstein) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal & local crazy tales! Email…

Episode #32: Nash & Tiff are taking a deep dive to talk about the true stories behind some legit sea monsters. And it's a MEGA EPISODE for our return from hiatus! (the 1916 Jersey Shore shark attacks, the sinking of The Essex) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @you…

Episode #31: Come along as Nash & Tiff continue taking a peek into the inner workings of some very nutty cults. (Benjamin Franklin, Francis Dashwood, the Hellfire Club) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal & loca…

Episode #30: Get ready for a wild ride, because this time Nash & Tiff are taking a peek into the inner workings of some very nutty cults. (Edmund Creffield, the Holy Rollers) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal …

Mini-Episode #12 : In which Nash & Tiff share the tales of a haunted castle with a wild history & a very unique English cryptid who lives in a tree. (Listener Suggestions: Franklin Castle, the Highclere Grampus) . Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or hometown stories, as well as suggest…

Episode #29: Come along as Nash & Tiff discuss a few famous locations where strange things have happened & wonder: are the events that took place really as mysterious as they seem? (the lost colony of Roanoke, the Bermuda Triangle) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram…

Episode #28: This time Nash & Tiff examine a collection of fairy tales & ask - could there be any truths behind them? Spoiler: yes! (Snow White, Margaretha von Waldeck, Maria Sophia von Erthal, Hansel & Gretel, Hans Traxler, Katharina Schraderin, Hans & Grete Metzler, the Pied Piper of Hamelin, Beauty & the Beast, Petrus Gonsalvus, Bluebeard, Conom…

Episode #27: Nash & Tiff are celebrating the first anniversary of You Totally Made That Up with a special "best of" episode full of their favorite moments from the past year! . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal …

Mini-Episode #11: In honor of Easter, Nash & Tiff tackle some unruly cryptid bunnies & tell you about the origins of the big bunny itself - plus some stuff about the history of the holiday, and what's up with the eggs, because hey why not? (Hosts' Choice: Jackalope, Wolpertinger, Milk Hare, Easter Bunny, Easter eggs, history of Easter) . Spooky Sna…

Episode #26: This time Nash & Tiff dish up some servings of super-creepy dolls, with a side of murder. (Robert the Doll, Arthur's Seat Dolls, Burke and Hare) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal & local crazy tal…

Mini-Episode #10: Nash brings you a special pandemic edition Spooky Snack about a lady who wouldn't wash her hands after she took a dump. If that doesn't sell you, we don't know what will. No but seriously, it's about asymptomatic carriers of disease and how denial is a helluva drug. (Hosts' Choice: Mary Mallon, Typhoid Mary) . Spooky Snacks are bi…

Episode #25: Come along as Nash & Tiff hit the high seas for some pirate talk. (Stede Bonnet, Anne Bonny) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal & local crazy tales! Email us: youtotallymadethatup@gmail.com |…

Mini-Episode #9: Nash & Tiff examine St. Patrick, along with some St. Patrick's Day traditions & leprechaun shenanigans. (Hosts' Choice: St. Patrick's Day history & traditions, leprechauns) Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or hometown stories, as well as suggestions for topics they'd l…

Episode #24: Join Nash & Tiff as they continue their journey through the veil to tell you some real-life... or, maybe not-so-real... ghost stories. (Scratching Fanny the Ghost of Cock Lane, the Hammersmith Ghost) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadetha…

Episode #23: Join Nash & Tiff as they slip into the veil & tell you some real-life... or, maybe not-so-real... ghost stories. (Nelly Butler) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal & local crazy tales! Email us: you…

Episode #22: Nash & Tiff discuss not one, but two bizarre series of axe murders that took place in Louisiana in the early 1900s. (the Axeman of New Orleans, Clementine Barnabet) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your person…

Mini-Episode #8: Nash & Tiff talk about a couple of winter “beings” & their weird backstories. (Hosts' Choice: Calleach Bheur, Beira, the Blue Hag of Winter, history of snowmen) Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or hometown stories, as well as suggestions for topics they'd like to hear …

Episode #21: It's wintertime, so join Nash & Tiff as they ponder upon what could be hiding in the snow. (Abominable Snowman, Yeti, Dyatlov Pass) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal & local crazy tales! Email us:…

Episode #20: This time Nash & Tiff are tackling astrology, telling you the stories of some astrologers who got more than they bargained for when they explored & popularized their beliefs. (Michel Gauquelin, the Mars Effect, John Partridge, Isaac Bickerstaff, Jonathan Swift) | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatu…

Episode #19: Merry Christmas from Nash & Tiff! Let's talk gremlins. (the Kelly-Hopkinsville goblin encounter, World War II gremlins) . | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! Email us: youtotally…

Mini-Episode #7: In which Nash fell down an Icelandic Christmas hole & drug Tiff along with her. (Hosts' Choice: Gryla, Yule Lads, the Yule Cat) Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or hometown stories, as well as suggestions for topics they'd like to hear us discuss, and sometimes things …

Episode #18: Nash & Tiff continue discussing their discovery that two of the world's favorite products have a history dipped in fake medicine & steeped in some serious woo. (the invention of Coca-Cola, John Pemberton) | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymade…

Episode #17: As Nash & Tiff discovered, two of the world's favorite products have a history dipped in fake medicine & steeped in some serious woo. (the invention of corn flakes, John Harvey Kellogg, Will Keith Kellogg) | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymad…

Mini-Episode #6: This Spooky Snack holds a nice surprise - we have a trio of hosts because we welcomed a guest on to discuss the cryptid they suggested we feature! Plus, we talk about a very Thanksgiving-esque creature that we’d never heard of, but boy are we glad we did. (Listener Suggestion: the Hodag, and Hosts' Choice: the Gobblesquatch) Spooky…

Episode #16: For this episode, Nash & Tiff got busy unwrapping mummies & investigating the curses associated with our desiccated dearly departeds. (Thomas Pettigrew, mummy unwrapping parties, King Tut's curse) | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |…

Episode #15: Murder! Mystery! Mayhem! It's the Halloween episode you've been waiting for - Nash & Tiff break down the truth & the fiction of a famous Halloween urban legend, tell some Halloween-related true crime cases, share how what you think you know about the origin of Halloween may not be correct, go over a variety of Halloween customs through…

Mini-Episode #5: This Spooky Snack is a little different, because we aren't telling your stories - we're telling one of ours! Tiff gives the rundown on a festival she traveled to that’s all about Wisconsin wendigos, including the history of the event, the things she saw, & people she met. And Nash gives background on the creatures, plus debates goi…

Episode #14: Nash & Tiff break down the mystery, the history, plus the science behind some scary games people play. (Ouija boards, Bloody Mary) | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! Email us: y…

Mini-Episode #4: Nash & Tiff talk rogue reptiles per a listener suggestion, then read a listener story that is definitely going to send shivers up your spine. (Listener Suggestion: the Crosswick Monster, and Listener Story: haunted house) Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or hometown st…

Episode #13: This time, Nash & Tiff go over a couple of incidents that prompted people to get scared & panic on major scales - but perhaps things weren't exactly as they seemed. (Spring-Heeled Jack, The War Of The Worlds broadcast) | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @…

Mini-Episode #3: Nash & Tiff share a follow-up on prison activities, address the many responses to the owl discussion, & read a listener's story about something they once stumbled upon whilst exploring their home. (Listener Story: a creepy basement discovery) Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, f…

Episode #12: Nash & Tiff head back to the Civil War era & separate some truth from fiction surrounding spiritualism & a very special First Lady. (Mary Todd Lincoln, William Mumler) | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your perso…

Mini-Episode #2 : Nash & Tiff explore Mansfield Reformatory, a.k.a. The Ohio State Reformatory, a.k.a. That Prison Where They Filmed Shawshank, a.k.a. This Place Is Haunted AF. (Listener Suggestion: Mansfield Reformatory/Ohio State Reformatory/Shawshank Prison) Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal,…

Episode #11: It's back to school time, so what better way to celebrate than hearing Nash & Tiff discuss a haunted campus & some creepy kids? (Clyde A. Erwin High School poltergeists, the Green Children of Woolpit) | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethat…

Episode #10: Are you alone in the house? Nash & Tiff investigate what might be the cause of those bumps in the night. (Theodore Coneys, Dolly Oesterreich) | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! …

Episode #9: Nash and Tiff talk witches, and *not* the same old tales of Salem. But turns out, there's actually a black cat. And a chicken. (Mary Bateman, Albert Shinsky) | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog | | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup | | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup | | We want to hear your personal & local…